GitLab vs GitHub vs Self-Hosted

GitHub and GitLab.com are both per-seat SaaS with CI minutes drawn from a shared pool. GitLab's self-managed tiers above its free Community Edition still carry a per-seat license. A fully self-hosted host like Rithub has neither a per-seat fee nor a shared-minutes ceiling.

The actual breakdown

GitHubGitLabSelf-hosted (Rithub)
HostingGitHub's cloud only (GitHub Enterprise Server is a separate paid SKU)GitLab.com cloud, or self-managedYour own server
Pricing modelPer-seat (Team/Enterprise), see per-seat pricing breakdownPer-seat on both SaaS and self-managed Premium/Ultimate tiersNo per-seat fee
CI/CDGitHub Actions, shared-minutes based by defaultGitLab CI, shared-minutes based on SaaSSelf-hosted runner, no minutes meter
Data locationGitHub's serversGitLab's servers (SaaS) or yours (self-managed)Always yours

Where "self-managed" stops being "self-hosted" on cost

GitLab's free Community Edition is genuinely self-hosted and license-free. Its Premium and Ultimate tiers add branch-protection rules, advanced CI/CD controls, and compliance features — but running those tiers yourself still means buying a per-seat license, the same cost shape as GitHub's Team/Enterprise plans, just deployed on your own server instead of GitLab's.

What actually removes per-seat cost and the minutes ceiling together

A host with no licensed tiers at all — Rithub, running on Gitea — has no per-seat charge at any scale and no shared CI minutes pool to run out of (see GitHub Actions minutes ran out). The trade-off, same as any self-hosted option, is operational: you run the server instead of a vendor running it for you.

Sign up freeImport from GitHub